121 Presbyterian Ave, Hanover
$485,500
4 Bedrooms
5 Baths
5790 Sq. Ft.
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 1
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 2
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 3
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 4
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 5
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 6
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 7
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 8
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 9
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 10
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 11
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 12
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 13
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 14
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 15
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 16
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 17
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 18
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 19
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 20
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 21
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 22
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 23
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 24
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 25
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 26
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 27
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 28
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 29
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 30
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 31
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 32
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 33
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 34
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 35
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 36
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 37
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 38
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 39
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 40
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 41
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 42
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 43
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 44
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 45
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 46
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 47
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 48
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 49
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 50
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 51
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 52
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 53
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 54
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 55
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 56
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 57
  • 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover IN 47243 | MLS 202509029 Photo 58
  • Property Details
    • Property Type:Single Family
    • MLS#:202509029
    • Status:Active
    • Sq. Feet:5790
    • On Site:2 Days
    • Lot Size:2.13 Acres
    • School System:N/A

    Greetings from Magnolia Manor!
    This magnificent home, situated on 2.13 acres in the heart of Hanover, offers the perfect blend of natural beauty, thoughtful updates, and spacious living all just minutes from town.
    Step onto a property unlike any other, lovingly curated over the years with an extraordinary collection of mature trees. In spring, daffodils bloom across the property, creating a truly magical scene, while fall dazzles with vibrant foliage in every direction. The home is equally enchanting. With plenty of living space, you'll find an inviting eat-in kitchen with quartz countertops, painted cabinetry, plus a formal dining room, year-round sunroom with floor-length windows, and a spacious family room in the basement perfect for entertaining. Bathrooms on each level add convenience, and the large patio and screened-in shelter house (2024) make outdoor hosting a breeze.
    Practical updates ensure peace of mind:
    New roof (Oct 2023),
    New windows throughout (2023 2024),
    HVAC system updated,
    Driveway resurfaced (2022),
    New storm doors (2022),
    Shelter house added in 2022, screened in 2024. Don't miss the chance to own a one-of-a-kind sanctuary where nature, space, and comfort come together. Welcome home to Magnolia Manor!

    Price History
    Price has not changed since being added to the site on 6/25/2025.
    Community Information
    Address:121 Presbyterian Ave
    County:Jefferson_In
    Neighborhood:N/A
    State:IN
    City:Hanover
    Zip Code:47243
    Architecture
    Bedrooms:4
    Bathrooms:3 Full / 2 Half
    Stories:1.5
    Year Built:1958
    Construction Materials: Brick, Frame
    Building Area: 5790.0
    Style:OneAndOneHalfStory
    Rooms
    SizeLevel
    Bedroom11 x 15.9First
    Bedroom11 x 18First
    Bedroom16.3 x 17.8First
    Bedroom9.6 x 60Second
    Living Room15 x 24.5First
    Dining Room11 x 13.8First
    Kitchen15.4 x 24.6First
    Family Room33 x 60Lower
    Other10.11 x 11First
    Other11.7 x 16.2First
    Other9.10 x 18First
    Property Features / Amenities
    Lot Size: 2.13 Acres
    View: Park/Greenbelt
    Lot Size (Sq.Ft.): 92782.8
    Garage Spaces: 2.0
    Parking Features: Attached, Detached, Garage, Garage Door Opener
    Sewer: Public Sewer
    Water: Connected, Public
    Road Surface: Paved
    Zoning: Agri/ Residential
    Interior Features: Ceiling Fan(s), Separate/Formal Dining Room, Bath in Master Bedroom, Skylights
    Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Water Softener, Trash Compactor
    Fireplace Features: Decorative
    Laundry: Main Level, Laundry Room
    Exterior Features: Landscaping, Paved Driveway
    Other Structures: Garage(s)
    Security Features: Radon Mitigation System
    Window: Skylights, Thermal Windows
    Basement: Finished
    Cooling: Central Air
    Heating: Heat Pump
    Total Rooms: 11
    Directions: Go to Hanover and turn on Presbyterian Ave. Home will be on the left.
    Tax and Financial Info
    Tax Annual Amount: $3, 479
    Terms: Cash, Conventional, FHA, USDA Loan, VA Loan
    Schedule a Showing / Request More Information
    Name*
    Email*
    Phone
    Agent
    9 + 4 =
     

    Listing Information Last Updated 6/26/2025

    The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program. Real estate listings held by IDX Brokerage firms other than F.C. Tucker/Scott Lynch Group are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo or the Internet Data Exchange thumbnail logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing IDX Brokers. This information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

    The Broker providing these data believes them to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm them before relying on them in a purchase decision. Information deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.

    FC Tucker Lynch Group

    FC Tucker Lynch Group

    (812) 265-3122
    Have a Question or need more info?
    Your Name* Your Email* Your Phone Currently working with one of our agents? Your Message View Full Message
     Loading Nearby Listings
    Home for sale at 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover, IN 47243 with the MLS 202509029 on FCTLynchGroup.com. The home at 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover, IN 47243 is currently for sale and features 4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, 5790 sq. ft. of living space, and is listed for sale at $485,500. You can search Indianapolis area properties for a home, a house, a condo, or a patio home to find real estate in Indianapolis, IN. You are viewing the official Indianapolis MLS listing details of the home for sale at 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover, IN 47243 which is MLS # 202509029. The home has been listed on this site for 1 days and is found in the neighborhood.
    Street View of 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover, IN 47243X
    Please note that Street View does not always initially point to the correct location.
    Bird's Eye View of 121 Presbyterian Ave Hanover, IN 47243X
    Please note that Bird's Eye View does not always initially point to the correct location.